Are you trying to decide between a responsive, holistic sleep coaching course and a more mainstream sleep training provider to kickstart your career as a sleep consultant? Wondering which approach will truly equip you to help families struggling with sleep—and which one actually aligns with your values?

You’re in the right place.

I know firsthand how overwhelming it can be to sort through different sleep coaching programs, each promising the best results. And here’s the thing—not all sleep coaching programs are created equal.

So today, I’m breaking it all down for you:

• The key differences between holistic and mainstream sleep coaching
• What mainstream sleep training doesn’t teach you—but should
• Why so many sleep consultants are choosing a gentle, responsive approach
•  And whether a holistic sleep coaching program is the right fit for you

Prefer watching? Check out the video below for a full breakdown of what to consider when choosing your sleep coaching path.

Table of Contents

1. What Are Your Options?
2. Why the Mainstream Approach Falls Short
3. Why Parents Are Choosing Gentle Sleep Coaching
4. What Does “Holistic” Even Mean?
5. Is a Holistic Approach Effective?
6. Concerns About a Gentle Approach
7. Do the Results Stick?

What Are Your Options?

“What’s the difference between holistic and mainstream sleep coaching?”

When choosing a sleep coaching program, you have two main options: holistic and mainstream.

🔹 Holistic Sleep Coaching: Focuses on the whole child and family, considering relationships, emotional regulation, child development, and more.
🔹 Mainstream Sleep Training: Often behaviorist, emphasizing routines and strategies like cry-it-out or controlled crying.

Want to dive deeper into how behaviourism influences mainstream sleep training? Check out this video, where we break down what behaviourist approaches mean and how they work.

Why the Mainstream Option Falls Short

“What are the downsides of mainstream sleep training?”

Many parents feel that mainstream methods, while simple, often fail to address their unique needs. Here’s why:

❌ Limited Personalization: Cookie-cutter solutions like prescribed naps or early bedtimes don’t work for every child.  I can’t tell you how many parents have told me that they felt like they had been given a template sleep plan with their child’s name cut and pasted into a generic plan that didn’t account for individual variables or needs. When they had questions about how to handle a certain scenario, or what to do if something wasn’t working, they felt like there was no answer.
❌ Cultural Insensitivity: Assumes universal sleep needs, ignoring cultural or individual differences. They fail to recognise the variability of sleep needs, and assume that children will be able to achieve sleep at the upper limit of the average-high sleep need range. That means it’s simply unrealistic and sets parents up to fail.
❌ Stress for Parents: Techniques like cry-it-out leave many parents feeling conflicted and uncomfortable. Lots of crying and more to the point, a focus on ignoring their instinct to respond. Now, while crying is just one way of communicating, and it’s not realistic to think that children will *never* cry, leaving a child alone in distress is something that most parents would rather avoid if possible.

Why Are Parents Choosing Gentle Sleep Coaching?

“Why is holistic sleep coaching so popular?”

Parents today are seeking alternatives to outdated, one-size-fits-all approaches. They want:

• Gentle, Responsive Options: Strategies that align with their parenting instincts.
• Realistic Solutions: Approaches that work with modern family dynamics and are sustainable long-term.
• Cultural Sensitivity: Solutions that respect their family’s unique values and traditions.

For more insights into why parents are shifting toward responsive sleep coaching, check out our video on the rising demand for gentle options.

What Does “Holistic” Even Mean?

“What is holistic sleep coaching?”

Holistic sleep coaching looks at more than just bedtime routines. It considers the entire family’s ecosystem, including:

• Relationships and attachment
• Emotional regulation and mental health
• Feeding and physical development

See how we define holistic coaching in our video exploring this approach.

What are the concerns with a gentle, holistic approach?

One of the most common concerns about a responsive approach to sleep is whether it actually works. Many believe that if you want a guaranteed outcome, you need a clear-cut, proven method—something with definitive steps and measurable effectiveness.

And it’s true—parents want results. As a committed professional with a strong work ethic, you want to ensure that when a family invests in your support, you can confidently provide strategies that work and help everyone get the rest they desperately need.

Maybe you’re thinking: “Gentle methods sound great in theory, but in my experience, parents don’t just want reassurance—they want solutions. They need to see real improvements in their child’s sleep, not just be told to ‘hang in there.’”

That’s a valid concern. After all, you’re here because you understand the toll of extreme sleep deprivation—perhaps you’ve even experienced it firsthand. The last thing you want is to invest in a program that fails to provide actionable, effective strategies to truly help exhausted families.

So first of all, let me say that a responsive approach isn’t just another way of telling parents to suck it up. Check out our earlier video on whether it’s possible to support the needs of parents as well as children simultaneously. 

So let’s move on to the effectiveness piece

Is a Holistic Option Effective?

“Does gentle sleep coaching work?”

A common belief is that mainstream sleep training methods like cry-it-out (CIO), controlled crying, and the Ferber method while acknowledged to be stressful are the fastest and most foolproof ways to improve infant sleep. But do these methods actually deliver on their promises?

Are These Methods Really Fast and Effective?

A recent study examining over 2,000 families evaluated four different sleep strategies:
1️Full Cry-It-Out (CIO) – Parents left their baby to cry until morning without intervention.
2️Controlled Crying – Parents intermittently reassured their baby at set intervals.
3️Parental Presence – A gentler method where parents remained in the room but minimized direct intervention.
4 No Sleep Training – Parents who chose not to actively modify their child’s sleep behavior.

And the results?

Total sleep duration was the same across all four groups. Despite common claims, children in sleep training programs did not sleep more than those in non-sleep-trained groups.

Night wakings also showed no significant differences. 

Babies in the CIO group woke an average of 3.6 times per night, while those in the parental presence and non-intervention groups woke 4.1 times per night—a marginal difference that hardly justifies the distress associated with CIO methods.

How Long Does Sleep Training Actually Take?

While CIO is often marketed as a quick fix, the reality is quite different.

• Cry-It-Out (CIO) took an average of 25 days for measurable sleep improvements—meaning nearly a month of leaving a baby to cry without comfort.
•  Controlled Crying—often considered a “gentler” alternative—took even longer at 32 days.
•  Parental Presence, the least stressful method, took 43 days—just 10 days longer than controlled crying, but with significantly less distress for both parent and child.

This aligns with broader behaviuoral change research, which suggests that it takes 6–8 weeks to form new habits—for both adults and infants. 

Given this, it’s not surprising that the most responsive approach (Parental Presence) took the expected time for behavioral adaptation while minimizing stress.

Do the Results Stick?

“Does holistic sleep coaching provide lasting results?”

Unlike cry-it-out methods that often need to be repeated after disruptions (illness, vacations, teething), holistic coaching addresses the root causes of sleep challenges.

So, now that we’ve covered why mainstream sleep training often falls short and how a holistic approach truly empowers families—what’s next?

You’re here because you care about helping families in a way that feels aligned with your values. And if you’re serious about getting trained in a method that is:

• Evidence-based (so you feel 100% confident supporting families)
• Holistic & responsive (without forcing one-size-fits-all solutions)
• Built for long-term success (so you create real transformation in people’s lives)

…then our Holistic Sleep Coaching Program might be the perfect fit for you.

👉 Book a strategy call with us today and let’s chat about your goals.

Don’t forget to subscribe to our YouTube channel for weekly videos on sleep coaching, business tips, and behind-the-scenes insights.

References:

scientific ref: Harries, V., & Brown, A. (2019). The association between use of infant parenting books that promote strict routines, and maternal depression, self-efficacy, and parenting confidence. Early Child Development and Care.

scientific ref: Paavonen, E. J., Saarenpää-Heikkilä, O., Morales-Munoz, I., Virta, M., Häkälä, N., Pölkki, P., … & Karlsson, L. (2020). Normal sleep development in infants: findings from two large birth cohorts. Sleep Medicine, 69, 145-154.

Theoretical explanations for maintenance of behaviour change: a systematic review of behaviour theories

How are habits formed: Modeling habit formation in the real world

Implementation of Behavioral Interventions for Infant Sleep Problems in Real-World Settings

Normal sleep development in infants: findings from two large birth cohorts

The association between use of infant parenting books that promote strict routines, and maternal depression, self-efficacy, and parenting confidence

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Toddler Sleep Coaching